Home > Blog > Church Leaders Must Lead Change

February 16, 2019

Church Leaders Must Lead Change

By Todd Adkins

Many of my childhood lessons have become quite helpful in different leadership roles I have held. Like most leadership lessons, you don’t appreciate them until later, sometimes much later. In college I realized I was a “swinger of birches,” as noted by Robert Frost in his famous poem.1 Let me explain.

I grew up in rural Kentucky. What Frost calls “swinger of birches” we called “skinning the cat.” This shenanigan involved finding young, tall, and thin trees that were trying to reach up through the canopy in the woods near my home. This act was best executed in spring or summer, when the tree sap was flowing and the trees were limber and growing. We would select a tree and climb almost to the top, at which point you commit and effectively jump out of the tree without letting go as it bends toward the ground. Few things in life are more satisfying than getting it just right, feeling weightless and looking almost otherworldly to those watching. Like a reverse pole vault in slow motion, I can tell you that you quickly learn to judge a tree, the time of year, the weather conditions, and how high you need to climb.

I learned this complex mixture of art and science as a 9-year-old boy, as these elements are in flux and the same tree may respond differently at different times of the year. If you climb a tree in the wrong season or when it is too dry, the tree will break in half which makes for a rough landing. If you don’t climb high enough and lean out too soon, then you are left hanging with little choice but to let go or hold on until help arrives. If you climb too high, you come in too hard and fast which can be even worse than when the tree breaks half way down. I personally experienced each of these scenarios.

While we usually “skinned the cat” in the presence of a group, my worst experience happened when I was by myself and leaned out too soon. I had climbed this tree before, but it was later in the summer and I had misjudged the situation, not paying attention to the way the tree felt as I climbed. I swung out from the tree with the expectation that it would bend to my will, the way it had before. Instead, I hung about 10 feet off the ground. I bounced to get it to go down, but it didn’t give much. I yelled for help, but no one heard me and eventually I bounced until the tree broke. I landed well enough to avoid a major injury and walked off the sprain on the way back to my house.

When I think about that day now, it feels almost synonymous as decision making and leading change for leaders. There comes a time when you must fully commit, part art and part science. If you get it wrong, then you are left hanging, crash hard, or fall. But if you get it right, you feel almost weightless, like gravity doesn’t matter and you are walking on the moon.

The Art and Science of Change

Leading change in any organization is both an art and a science. You must understand the conditions and establish a plan, but everyone has a great plan until they are left hanging 10 feet off the ground. The failure to recognize the art of feeling usually gets leaders in the end. You must understand both what is going on with the people and the environment as you process change implementation.

I used to say that if you can’t lead people, then you can’t lead change. But I’m beginning to believe that if you can’t lead change, then you can’t lead people either. Being a leader in any church or organization will mean leading change. There is no other option.

In the past, a leader may have led one or two major changes throughout his or her career. Now, major changes happen every 5-10 years. In an age of ever increasing access to information, data, and opinion, it feels like we need a degree in chaos theory to move forward. Never have we had a greater need to implement change and never have we had so many tools at our disposal, but I am afraid this access has lead to greater confusion than its intended effect.

Often leaders recognize a change is desperately needed, so they choose the latest and greatest plan. This plan is thorough, clear to communicate, has great visuals, and can be explained on a single sheet of paper. The rollout plan for change is both logically and theological sound, but it goes off the rails early. Or maybe worse, you implement every step and nothing changes. You just seemed to put a new coat of paint on the status quo.

We must remember that leadership and change management remain both an art and a science.

  1. Edward Connery Lathem, ed., The Poetry of Robert Frost (New York: Henry Holt and Company), 122.

Adapted from Leading Change in Your Church. Download the FREE ebook here.


Todd Adkins

Todd Adkins (@ToddAdkins) is the Director of Leadership at LifeWay. Prior to LifeWay, Todd served as an executive pastor at McLean Bible Church. He has a background in launching strategic initiatives and scalable campus models to provide immediate growth while remaining financially solvent. During his time at LifeWay, Todd has introduced customizable, web-based leadership development through MinistryGrid.com. He is passionate about helping churches build a Leadership Pipeline and develop Training Pathways for every role in the church.


view all
Business Leadership and the Church

Exclusive Content

Succeeding in Church Planting

Exclusive Content

Should I Plant a House Church?

Exclusive Content

The Church Is Not the Building

Exclusive Content

Cultivating Leadership and Outreach [Behind-The-Scenes]
Developing Leadership and Outreach in a Church

Exclusive Content